Research Reports |
RL Mizner, PT, MPT, is a doctoral student, Biomechanics and Movement Science Program, Department of Physical Therapy, University of Delaware, Newark, Del
JE Stevens, PT, MPT, PhD, was a doctoral student, Biomechanics and Movement Science Program, University of Delaware, at the time of the study. Dr Stevens is currently Post-doctoral Associate, Department of Physical Therapy, University of Florida
L Snyder-Mackler, PT, ScD, SCS, ATC, is Professor, Department of Physical Therapy, University of Delaware, 301 McKinly Laboratory, Newark, DE 19716 (USA) (smack{at}udel.edu).
Address all correspondence to Dr Snyder-Mackler
Submitted May 22, 2002;
Accepted October 28, 2002
Key Words: Knee replacement Muscle inhibition Volitional activation
|
|
|---|
Despite the relationship between knee extension force and functional ability, decreased quadriceps femoris muscle performance after TKA has gone relatively unexamined. Investigators16 have measured knee extension force as an outcome variable months to years after surgery. Although these studies provide valuable information for understanding the long-term condition of the knee extensors following TKA, they do not provide information concerning the cause of this persistent decrease in force. The early period after surgery has received little scrutiny, yet this period is when patients typically begin outpatient rehabilitation to address, among other things, decreased quadriceps femoris muscle performance.
Both atrophy and failure of volitional activation of the quadriceps femoris muscle have been suggested as causes of deceased muscle force in people with knee osteoarthritis as well as in older adults.1218 Failure of voluntary activation can be operationally defined as the inability to produce all available force of a muscle despite maximal conscious effort.1921 A failure of voluntary activation can result from pain,22 effusion,23,24 and joint damage,13 all of which are potentially present in patients after TKA.
Diminished activation has been implicated as a contributing factor in preventing rapid and full recovery of quadriceps femoris muscle force following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and in patients with painful patellofemoral disorders.16,19,25 Typically, twitch-interpolation or burst superimposition of electrical stimulation has been used to quantify the extent of voluntary activation failure of a muscle.16,21 Neither technique has been used to examine activation deficits in patients after TKA. Determining the extent of voluntary activation of patients may prove critical to designing and implementing effective rehabilitation programs. Hurley et al14 reported that strength training, which included 4 weeks of intensive isokinetic training to address decreased quadriceps femoris muscle performance, had limited success in resolving voluntary activation failure and improving force production in patients with a substantial activation failure. The purposes of our investigation were: (1) to quantify the extent of quadriceps femoris muscle force deficits and voluntary activation deficits in patients who had undergone TKA compared with older people without known knee pathology and (2) to determine the effect of knee pain and age on the voluntary activation of the knee extensors of the lower extremity that underwent the TKA. We hypothesized that (1) patients after TKA would have lower normalized quadriceps femoris muscle force and decreased voluntary activation when compared with a group of older adults without knee pathology, (2) pain and age would account for a large portion of the variability in voluntary activation after surgery, and (3) voluntary activation in the TKA group would account for a large portion of the variability in force production.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table. Group Descriptionsa
|
Muscle Force and Voluntary Activation Measurement
All subjects participated in a measurement session of a maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) of the quadriceps femoris muscle with a burst superimposition technique. They were seated in an electromechanical dynamometer (Kin-Com 500 H).* The TKA group sat with the hip flexed to 90 degrees and the knee flexed to 75 degrees, and the comparison group sat with the hip and knee flexed to 90 degrees. The arthroplasty group was tested at 75 degrees instead of 90 degrees because we anticipated that a relatively large number of subjects either would be unable to achieve 90 degrees of flexion at 3 to 4 weeks after surgery or would be unable to achieve that range without pain.
The axis of the dynamometer was positioned at the axis of rotation of the knee joint, and the distal edge of the shin attachment was placed 2 in (5.08 cm) proximal to the lateral malleolus of the test leg. A waist and a trunk strap were used for stabilization. Two self-adhesive electrodes (7.6 cm x 12.7 cm)
were placed over the quadriceps femoris muscle at the motor point of the vastus medialis and proximal rectus femoris muscles (Fig. 1). Subjects performed 2 submaximal contractions and 1 MVIC lasting 2 to 3 seconds each in order to warm up the muscle and to familiarize the patient with the testing procedure.
![]() View larger version (97K): [in a new window] |
Figure 1. Electrode placement for burst superimposition testing.
|
) delivered a supramaximal electrical stimulus of monophasic rectangular waves at a rate of 100 pulses per second for 100 milliseconds at 135 V. The knee extension force was measured and recorded using custom-written software (Labview 4.0.1 and 5.0)
with a 200-Hz sampling rate. If maximal voluntary force output was achieved and no augmentation of force was observed due to the stimulation (ie, there was already optimal recruitment), then the testing session was concluded for that limb. If augmentation was present during the application of the electrical stimulus, the test was repeated. Five minutes of rest was provided between contractions in an effort to minimize muscular or neuromuscular fatigue. A maximum of 3 trials was recorded. The highest volitional force achieved during the 3 attempts was used for analysis. A weight correction was performed automatically by the computer program by adding the baseline force while the patient was relaxed to the force measurement. Burst superimposition testing was performed on the uninvolved limbs of the TKA group and then on the operated limb. Only the right lower extremity was tested in the comparison group. The burst superimposition technique has been shown to be highly reliable in subjects without pathology (mean age=24.2 years, range=1732), with repeated testing that demonstrated an intraclass correlation coefficient of .98.26
Pain Measurement
A numeric rating scale was used to quantify knee pain during burst superimposition testing. Subjects with TKA were asked to verbally rate the pain in and around the knee during the burst superimposition test on a scale from 0 to 10, where 0 represented no pain and 10 represented the worst pain imaginable. Subjects were asked to rate only knee pain and not the discomfort in the thigh associated with the level of electrical stimulation during test. The knee pain rating given during the attempt that produced the greatest force was used for analysis. Numeric rating scales are easy to administer and have exhibited a Pearson product moment correlation of greater than .94 in within day test-retest collections in people with arthritis.27
Data Management and Analysis
Two measures of knee extension force production were used for analysis: peak volitional force normalized to BMI and a quadriceps index (QI). Peak volitional force was normalized to allow for comparison with the uninjured group. The QI was determined by dividing the MVIC of the involved quadriceps femoris muscle by the MVIC of the contralateral, uninvolved quadriceps femoris muscle.
The extent of failure of volitional activity of the quadriceps femoris muscle during the testing was quantified using the central activity ratio (CAR) described by Kent-Braun and Le Blanc.28 The CAR was calculated by dividing the maximal volitional force by the maximal force produced by the combination of volitional effort and a superimposed burst (Fig. 2). A CAR of 1 indicates complete activation of the muscle with no augmentation of the maximal volitional force observed during the burst of electrical stimulation.
![]() View larger version (12K): [in a new window] |
Figure 2. Example of a force trace recorded during a burst superimposition test of the quadriceps femoris muscle. The central activation ratio (CAR) for this test is 0.76 (maximal volitional force [135 N]/maximal force during burst of stimulation [178 N]). TKA=total knee arthroplasty, MVIC=maximal voluntary isometric contraction.
|
|
|
|---|
Linear regression analysis indicated that age of the TKA group did not explain the variance in the CAR variable (Fig. 3). The knee pain of the TKA group during burst superimposition testing showed a small relationship to CAR (r2=.17) (Fig. 4). Only half (26 of 52) of the subjects with TKA reported knee pain during burst superimposition testing. The subjects in the TKA group who had knee pain during testing had greater failure of volitional activation than those without knee pain (Fig. 5). Volitional activation of the TKA group explained a large portion of the variance in their QI with a curvilinear model of regression (r2=.65) (Fig. 6).
![]() View larger version (14K): [in a new window] |
Figure 3. Graphic representation of the linear relationship between the age of subjects with total knee arthroplasty and the amount of volitional activation of their involved quadriceps femoris muscle 3 to 4 weeks after surgery.
|
![]() View larger version (13K): [in a new window] |
Figure 4. Relationship between volitional activation and knee pain during burst superimposition testing. NRS=numeric rating scale.
|
![]() View larger version (17K): [in a new window] |
Figure 5. Comparison of volitional activation of knees of subjects with a total knee arthroplasty grouped by those with or without pain during burst superimposition testing. MVIC=maximal voluntary isometric contraction.
|
![]() View larger version (18K): [in a new window] |
Figure 6. Exponential regression analysis showing the model of quadriceps index (side-to-side muscle force comparison) accounting for the variance in central activation ratio.
|
|
|
|---|
Knee pain appears to contribute a small amount to the failure of voluntary activation, and we believe this is a relevant clinical finding to consider in developing rehabilitation protocols. We believe that efforts to increase muscle force production in patients with painful quadriceps femoris muscle contraction should take into consideration that these patients are more likely to have muscle inhibition. Simply eliminating pain will not provide the panacea for eliminating knee extension inhibition.
The subjects' age did not provide additional information for identifying those subjects with volitional activity deficits. Researchers12,21 have identified small age-related deficits in volitional activation of the quadriceps femoris muscle in older adults. In our study, any age-related deficits in volitional activation were likely negligible in the presence of the large activation failure we observed.
Younger patients will likely undergo TKA as the durability of prostheses continues to improve. Current prosthetic devices have a revision rate of less than 10% up to 20 years following surgery. Knee replacement in younger patients is also supported by previous studies that showed that patients with greater function, as measured by self-assessment questionnaire, prior to surgery achieved the greatest functional status following surgery.3 The results of our study show that even a relatively young patient (ie, 5055 years of age) who has had a TKA is not immune from exhibiting extensive failure of volitional activation with a related decrease in quadriceps femoris muscle force following surgery. Chronic, weak knee extensor muscles may make longer functional life of a total knee prosthesis impossible.
Failure of volitional activation may play an important role in the cause of the persistent decreased quadriceps femoris muscle production in patients following TKA. Volitional activation deficits of the quadriceps femoris muscle found in studies of patellofemoral dysfunction and knee osteoarthritis have been shown to relate to decreased quadriceps femoris muscle production.15,17,19,22 Manal and Snyder-Mackler19 showed that patients with volitional activity deficits with patellar contusions had more than twice the percentage of decreased quadriceps femoris muscle force than those without reflex inhibition. The average failure of activation of the patients with reflex inhibition and patellar contusion was 14%. The average failure of activation of the TKA group in our study (26%) was considerably larger.
Our data illustrate that decreased quadriceps femoris muscle performance is present 1 month after TKA. Muscle force measurements are not often a part of the assessment of outcomes, whereas reduction in pain following surgery is often enough to lead to claims of excellent surgical success.5 We believe the strong relationship between quadriceps femoris muscle force production and performance during stair climbing, gait, and transfers6,10,11 should not be ignored. Simply achieving pain relief and restoring a functional range of motion in the postoperative knee does not preclude striving for resolution of decreased quadriceps femoris muscle production. Inadequate quadriceps femoris muscle rehabilitation could have long-term negative consequences in patient outcomes and may lead to increased fall risk with advancing age.
|
|
|---|
This study was approved by the Human Subjects Review Board of the University of Delaware.
This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health (#1R01HD041055-01A1) and the Foundation for Physical Therapy (Mary McMillan Scholarship, PODS I and II Scholarships). The authors will receive no financial benefit from the publication of these findings.
* Chattecx Corp, 6431 Pythian Rd, Harrison, TN 37341-3902. ![]()
CONMED Corp, 310 Broad St, Utica, NY 13501. ![]()
Grass Instruments, 570 Liberty St, Braintree, MA 02184. ![]()
National Instruments, 6504 Bridge Point Pkwy, Austin, TX 78730. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. L. Mizner, S. C. Petterson, J. E. Stevens, K. Vandenborne, and L. Snyder-Mackler Early Quadriceps Strength Loss After Total Knee Arthroplasty. The Contributions of Muscle Atrophy and Failure of Voluntary Muscle Activation J. Bone Joint Surg. Am., May 1, 2005; 87(5): 1047 - 1053. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||